Is the gold price stabilization policy truly effective?
- 3
- Business
- 11:02 23/08/2024
DNHN - Dr. Bùi Duy Tùng, an Economics lecturer at RMIT University, assesses the pros and cons of the gold price stabilization policies implemented by the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) in recent times.
According to Dr. Tùng, these policies have contributed to narrowing the gap between domestic and global gold prices. Currently, the domestic gold price is only about 5 million VND per tael higher than the global price, compared to the significant difference of 16-17 million VND per tael in the early months of the year.
Moreover, the situation of "goldization" has been controlled. The policy of selling gold through commercial banks has helped reduce people's demand for hoarding gold, thereby decreasing the phenomenon of goldization in the market. This has contributed to short-term stability in the gold market.
The current gold selling mechanism has helped ease the "gold fever" in the country, as people no longer rush to buy gold as before. This helps stabilize the market and prevent goldization. By keeping the SJC gold bar price stable, the SBV has helped maintain consumer and investor confidence, avoiding a rush to buy gold that could lead to uncontrollable gold fevers. This has reduced pressure on the gold market and avoided negative economic consequences.
However, the gold price stabilization policies still have some drawbacks.
First, the gold trading network has been narrowed. The SBV's decision to sell gold through only four commercial banks and SJC has reduced the gold trading network, making it difficult for people to access gold, especially in provinces outside of Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City. This reduces market vibrancy and hinders people with a demand for gold.
Second, the process of buying and selling gold has become more complicated. The current process, which requires online registration, a waiting period of a few days to receive gold, and a limited number of sales points, has reduced flexibility and created difficulties for people. This has discouraged many from participating in gold transactions. Since only commercial banks and SJC are allowed to sell but not buy gold, many people feel unsafe investing in gold. The lack of options to resell gold has made people less interested in gold as an investment channel.
Third, the market lacks supply-demand balance. Although the SBV has taken measures to stabilize gold prices, overly strict control may lead to long-term imbalances, such as the emergence of black markets and unauthorized gold trading. The SJC gold bar market has become less dynamic, with sluggishness and a lack of liquidity.
The sharp decline in gold trading has made the market less attractive to investors. Prolonged administrative management measures can lead to negative issues such as the formation of black markets, the appearance of fake gold, and fraud in gold transactions. This can erode public confidence in the official gold market.
Fourth, the policies have not yet eliminated the monopoly of the SJC gold brand. The current policy still maintains the monopoly of the SJC gold bar brand, which may lead to unreasonable price disparities and fail to ensure fair competition in the market. The SBV's continued monopoly on gold imports also limits supply, leading to shortages and unnecessary price increases.
Fifth, the price of gold rings has risen above that of gold bars. As SJC gold bars have become harder to buy due to limited sales, consumers have turned to gold rings. The rise in gold ring prices above SJC gold bars due to the shift in consumer demand highlights the imbalance in market management.
The gold bar price stabilization policy has created a "whack-a-mole" effect, causing gold ring prices to rise sharply and potentially continue rising, leading to market instability. The SBV's strong intervention in managing SJC gold bar prices can distort the gold market. When gold bar prices are kept low compared to gold ring prices, this may encourage speculative behavior or unwanted capital flows, causing long-term instability in the market.
Ngoc Hoang (RMIT)
Related news
#develop policies
Why is there a need for a development proposal in the field of cultural industries?
In the context of globalization and the booming creative economy, cultural industries are increasingly important in national development strategies. Vietnam needs a development proposal in this field to tap into its potential.
Digital transformation in Bình Thuận: An inevitable trend for economic development
Digital transformation is an inevitable trend, and Bình Thuận needs to accelerate the application of technology across various economic sectors.
FDI continues to flow strongly into real estate
Among investment sectors, real estate continues to attract significant FDI. This raises the question of why FDI continues to pour into this sector.
Practical applications of carbon credits in the economy. Part XI: Bridging policy and strategy for the carbon credit market
To develop the carbon credit market, the Government and businesses must improve cooperation and communication. The Government needs to provide clear policies, while businesses must adopt emission reduction strategies and leverage carbon credits.
When will urban railways in Vietnam truly accelerate?
Although the Cát Linh-Hà Đông line has been operational, many urban railway projects are still facing difficulties in terms of progress and financing. To achieve a breakthrough in development, close coordination is needed.
What are the main challenges facing Vietnam's economy on the path to sustainable development?
Vietnam is facing significant challenges in economic development due to its reliance on resources and cheap labor.
Đọc thêm Business
Apartment prices continue to rise far beyond workers' incomes
Apartment prices continue to rise sharply, increasingly out of reach for workers' incomes. This gap not only creates significant financial pressure but also makes homeownership increasingly difficult for the majority of people.
The stock market faces increasing selling pressure, VN-Index sank into the red
The strong selling pressure across the market, especially in the blue-chip stocks, has caused the VN-Index to drop sharply, even falling below the 1,270-point mark at times.
VREC and HREC create opportunities for member businesses to connect with Nippon Paint Vietnam
Recently, at the headquarters of Nippon Paint Vietnam, the Vietnam Real Estate Club (VREC) and the Ho Chi Minh City Real Estate Club (HREC) successfully organized a networking event for member businesses.
Cash flow real estate: New investment trend in 2024
Cash flow real estate has become an investment trend in 2024 due to its stable profitability from leasing and business operations. Interest in this type of real estate demonstrates the demand for sustainable profits in an uncertain economic context.
Why is there a need for a development proposal in the field of cultural industries?
In the context of globalization and the booming creative economy, cultural industries are increasingly important in national development strategies. Vietnam needs a development proposal in this field to tap into its potential.
Mastering Real Estate Business Law to be ready for the next growth cycle
In the context of the changing real estate market alongside new legal regulations, understanding the Real Estate Business Law is a crucial factor for businesses and investors to seize opportunities and prepare well for the new cycle.
The impact of FDI on the growth of serviced apartments
Foreign direct investment (FDI) stimulates the growth of serviced apartments by increasing demand from international experts. FDI drives market expansion, particularly in rapidly developing areas.
"Vietnam's startup ecosystem in 2024 remains on a path of promising development"
This is also the assessment of Dr. Chu Duc Hoang, Chief of Office of the National Technology Innovation Fund, when evaluating the overall picture of Vietnamese startups from the beginning of 2024.
Export-import credit is entering a “busy season”
Export-import credit is entering a bustling season, with increased activities to support businesses in expanding their international markets. Banks and financial institutions are ramping up funding, meeting the growing demand in global trade.
Why is credit growth showing signs of slowing down?
Recently, credit growth has shown signs of slowing down, which has attracted the attention of many economic analysts and policymakers. Several factors have contributed to the slowdown in credit growth.